Business Standard
Saturday, Nov 21, 2009
 
drived banner
drived banner
  Advanced Search
Feedback | RSS
Content Guide
Follow us on  
  Home  ||||||||| 
 BS Headlines | News Now | BS Weekend | The strategist | The Smart Investor | Lunch with BS | Columnists | BS 1000
  Hindi | E-Paper | Motoring  | Live Markets |  Smart Portfolios II  | Blogs | Portfolios >
  Search:
Sunita Narain: The business of protest
Sunita Narain / New Delhi May 23, 2008, 2:23 IST

From SLAPPs to hiring professional protesters, industry's working overtime to find new ways to attack.

In the first week of April this year, a group of men came and stood outside the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), New Delhi. They carried placards with offensive slogans directed at me. We understood the picket to be the latest in a dangerous pesticide industry mindgame.

Let me explain. For the past few years, the pesticide industry, represented by its rich and powerful owners, has held press conferences across the country slamming CSE's research on pesticide residues in food, in the blood of farmers in the Punjab and in the soil, water and food of diseased and deformed villagers of Padre in Kerala. During this period, we have received dozens of legal notices from this industry, threatening dire consequences. Every time we have replied to these notices, stating the facts, but there has not been a follow-up. Instead, another notice for some other frivolous reason gets sent, threatening dire consequences. A year ago, they hit a real low when they began circulating obscene cartoons of me.

In all this time, even as we refused to give in to the threats, we also respected their right to protest. This time, too, we decided to leave the picket alone. Then, a few days into the ‘protest', a journalist with a city daily visited and recognised one of the protesters outside our gate. This was not an employee of the aggrieved pesticide company or a protesting NGO, he said. This man was a representative of a public relations company who had met him, on behalf of biscuit manufacturers, to make the case that the government should allow processed food, instead of cooked hot meals, in the multi-crore school meal programme.

We were puzzled. Surely, Indian industry was too proud or forthright to hire protesters? Why would reputed public relations companies engage in dirty tricks and intimidation? We knew this kind of thing happened in the US, where corporations hired lobbyists and white-collared goons. But was this now happening in India?

When we checked with all known names in the public relations business, nobody had heard of this company. Finally, when my colleagues tracked it down to a small office based in a Mumbai suburb, we learnt it represented the biggest of the polluters — the plastic industry and pesticide industry — as well as others, like the biscuit manufacturers, to defend their interests. The company boss proudly told my colleague he was out demonstrating in front of our office. But in the same breath, he told her he had nothing to do with the protest. We realised why. His was a ‘shadow' affair. This was the new face of Indian business — the hidden lobbyist who could skillfully make out cases for clients in different ways, from power-point presentations to physical protest, all on hire, for a price.

Clearly, this is now the toolkit of industry to deal with dissent — to suppress public opinion and to subvert decision-making via a fine public relations makeover. If you don't believe me, consider how, in this same period, the pesticide industry has filed countless cases against activists and scientists, but with an important difference. These cases derive from what is known in the US as SLAPP — acronym for ‘strategic lawsuits against public participation'. These are ‘different' because the corporation uses it not to get justice, but to threaten, intimidate and gag. The cases are filed not against institutions that can defend their interests, but against individuals and, in particular, professionals who refuse to prostitute their science to suit industry.

A few years ago, the Pesticide Association of India, now called the Crop Care Foundation of India, sent Y S Mohana Kumar, the lone doctor in Padre, a strong legal notice threatening massive damages. His crime? He had worked tirelessly among villagers afflicted with terrible mental and physical ailments that pesticide residue poisoning had caused, and had raised the issue publicly. Padre is a village devastated by the spraying of endosulfan; every house has a victim crying for justice. The industry continues to deny its shame. Instead, it continues to threaten and abuse. The latest victim is a retired government scientist who undertook the research that indicted pesticides for the ailments in poisoned Padre. Till she worked with the Ahmedabad-based National Institute of Occupational Health, industry and its agents did nothing. But the moment she retired, the attacks began. She has already received two legal notices, and more threats, we know, will follow. Industry wants to ensure that others do not ‘dare' to do science that works for public good.

Even as I write this, I know that the dirty tricks department of the pesticide industry is working over-time to find innovative ways to attack. Last week they decided to up the ante — to target my house so that they can harass my 80-year-old mother. But we all know there is too much at stake here to let a few sticks and stones break our bones.

Arrow Other Stories     
- Sensex makes remarkable recovery, regains 17K
- S C Kalia takes over as Union Bank ED
- PNB may acquire majority stake in Kazakh bank
- Maoist hindering land acquisition for Tata steel project: Raman
- Koda says he will report to ED only after Jharkhand polls
More  
  Read Business news in 
  Get financial advisory and solutions for your projects
  Holidays starting at a delightful EMI of Rs 3481
  Switch on and say hello to Monday morning !
  Your dream home can now be a reality.
  Visit Fortis for a preventive health check-up & get a 20% discount.
  Follow the ups and downs of your investments. Try our new Portfolio Tracker
  Kolkata Dock \ Freight contract for the British Gurkhas Nepal
  Find how Midsize Businesses use ERP to gain competitive advantage
  Trading in Forex is now as easy as 1-2-3
  Discover an economical and cost effective way to market your products and services
  Giftwithlove.com: Same day delivery of Flowers and Cakes to India
  Download the E-book on the Future of Business Intelligence
  Learn Best Practices for improving customer satisfaction
  Know your customers better... download the free e-book on CRM
   Discussion Board / User Comments    
Display Name  Email-Id  
Post your comment
springpondbver
After 45 years in pest control, I have just finished re-writing my free IPM encyclopedia entitled: THE BEST CONTROL II, that contains over 2,800 safe and far more effective alternatives to pesticide POISONS. This latest copyrighted work is free and about 1,800 pages in length and is at http://www.stephentvedten.com/ . There is simply no need to POISON yourself or your family or to have any pest problems.
Reply
drsbanerji
Business organizations and public relations are both legitimate entities and endeavors. Litigation is a fundamental right. Personal suspicions about the proponents of criminal activities should be directed to the police. Editors should not allow publications to be abused for surreptitious mud-slinging. Endosulfan can and has been used for safe and effective aerial spraying. The tragedy of Kerala relates to abuse from application on isolated trees without professional ground support
Reply
vishal_haria
I wonder why such news are not published by the media. These ailments can only be fought when public is with the 'lone fighter'. And to educate public is media's job! Instead of waking up to read all negative news on front page everyday, I would like that I wake up to news that can make difference in our lives.
Reply
Most Popular
Read
E-Mailed
Commented
   
- Bharti Airtel slashes roaming rates by 60%
- Govt may allow private sector investment in education
- Network18 lays off 200 staffers
- Suzlon Energy's three promoters pledge 2.8 cr shares
- Patni may host all IT services on 'cloud'
 
 More  
BS Poll
Cast Your Vote
 
   
 
Should India's defence sector be thrown open to foreign investments?
  Yes  No
Submit

  Hot Searches  
 
Amitabh Bachchan | N Chandrasekaran | Swine Flu | Mukesh Ambani | Anil Ambani | TCS | Infosys |  Air India |  Duronto |  Pranab Mukherjee | Sonia Gandhi | Congress | Rahul Gandhi |  Bigg Boss |  New Pension Scheme |  Service tax |  Excise duty |  Sebi | Tech Mahindra |  Ramalinga Raju |  Satyam |  Reliance  |  RBI |  GDP |  Gold |  Ratan Tata |  ICICI |  |  B-School | DLF  Sensex |  Tax calculator | Home Loan  | Bollywood | Personal Finance |  inflation | oil prices |  World Bank | Reliance Infratel |  HDFC |  Barack Obama  
  Member Area Write to the Editor RSS Archives Advanced Search
  Subscribe to BS print product BS e-paper Newsletter Portfolio Tracker
  BS Products BS Hindi BS Motoring
FOR HOT PRODUCTS
BS Bazaar.com
Home | Markets & Investing | Companies & Industry | Banking & Finance | Economy & Policy | Opinion
Life & Leisure | Management & Marketing | Tech World
About Us | Partner With Us | Code of Conduct | Careers | Advertise with us| Terms & Conditions | Disclaimer | Site Map | Contact Us | Feedback