Business Standard

Will plan panel poverty numbers enrich UPA in 2014 polls?

India needs a broader and more realistic de facto definition of the poor

Related News

Will in India ‘officially’ end in a decade? If we scrutinise the Planning Commission’s  latest statistics thoroughly, it suggests so if the current trend continues. Arguably, the plan panel claims that poverty incidence had declined from 37.2% of the population in 2004-05 to 21.9% in 2011-12 — a decline of 15.3 percentage points in a period that roughly coincides with the first eight years of the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) rule at the Centre.

In absolute terms, 137.4 million people were lifted above the poverty line over the seven-year period. Compared with 407.2 million poor people in 2004-05, the number came down to 269.7 million in 2011-12 — a reduction of 33%.
 
On Thursday, after leader Raj Babbar's comment that a hearty meal in Mumbai can be bought for Rs 12 triggered a nation-wide controversy, another leader Raseed Massod claimed just Rs 5 was sufficient for it in Delhi. Can a party that claims to be pro-poor tolerate shockingly insensitive comments made by their leaders? To exploit the Commission data advocating decline in poverty backfired on the Congress as the focus shifted to concerns over rising inflation and the inequality between the rich and the poor.

The pertinent questions about inflation and inadequate resources available with the under-privileged drowned the bid after figures on the so-called poverty meltdown became public. According to the latest poverty estimate, those who are desperately poor in the country have to subsist on just Rs 33.33 per day in urban areas and Rs 27.20 in rural areas. This is marginally higher than the figures tentatively announced last March of Rs 32 in urban areas and Rs 26 in rural areas.

The Poverty Line for 2011-12 has been estimated at Rs 816 per capita per month in rural areas and Rs 1000 in urban areas for the year 2011-12. That means a family of five living on the edge of poverty would have to survive on Rs 4,080 per month in rural areas and Rs 5,000 per month in urban areas, according to the Planning Commission.

Despite the recent uproar over the appallingly low level at which the Suresh Tendulkar committee set the poverty line, the government has chosen to stick officially with that line even though it knows that for all practical purposes the incidence of actual poverty is nearly three times higher.
 
While the plan panel-derived poverty lines and estimates have been all-important in the past because they are used to draw up BPL lists and allot entitlements, their inappropriateness is demonstrated by the fact that the government itself is now moving away from using these numbers altogether. According to a report in The Hindu,  Rukmini S and MK Venu say that following the Cabinet’s clearing of the National Food Security Ordinance, the plan panel has estimated that subsidised foodgrain entitlements will cover 67% of the population. Simultaneously, economists advising the Ministry of Rural Development have told the southern-based newspaper that the exclusion criteria to be derived from the ongoing Socio-Economic and Caste Census are likely to leave out the top 35% of the population while the bottom 65% will be considered below poverty line (BPL).
 
The article further quoting Planning Commission member Saumitra Chaudhuri says that by covering 67% of the population, the government is in effect drawing the poverty line 85% higher than what it is currently drawn at.
 
The poverty numbers are estimated on the basis of consumption expenditure captured in the five-year surveys undertaken by the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO). The decline in poverty numbers was first reported by The Hindu on 16 July.
 
The last one was made in 2009-10. Logically, the next one should have been in 2014-15.  But 2009-10 was not a “normal year” because of a severe drought. That’s why the NSS decided to repeat the large-scale survey in 2011-12. Breaking with the tradition of bringing it out every five years, the Manmohan Singh  government came under scathing attack for bringing out the poverty estimate three years ahead of schedule.
 
The World Bank has adopted a universal thumb rule: it says those living on less than $1.25 a day should be considered poor. The rupee’s value against the dollar averaged 47.85 in 2011-12. The purchasing power parity (PPP) rate for the rupee against the dollar could be arrived at by dividing the average exchange rate by 2.55. So, at the 2011-12 exchange rate of Rs 47.85 a dollar, the PPP rate would be Rs 18.76. The $1.25 poverty line at that PPP rate would mean Rs 23.45 — less than India’s poverty line for both rural and urban areas as announced for 2011-12. 
 
Some economists are of the view that economic realities, such as high inflation, rent and commodities, mean it is impossible to make even bare minimum purchases of food with such small amounts of money. The average cost of 1 kilogram of rice sold through the government’s public distribution system at subsidised rates for instance is currently around Rs18-20. The estimates don’t present a real picture of the number of those who live in very poor conditions, critics add. NC Saxena, a former bureaucrat who monitors food programmes on behalf of the Supreme Court of India, says the estimates of numbers living in poverty are meaningless in the current economic climate, reports the WSJ.
 
The formula used to measure poverty in the current report had been suggested in 2009 by Suresh Tendulkar. It had been widely criticised for underestimating consumption expenditure in the country. Last June, the Planning Commission had appointed a committee headed by C. Rangarajan, chairman of the Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council, to revise the poverty measurement formula. The committee is expected to submit its report in the middle of next year.

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|
|

Will plan panel poverty numbers enrich UPA in 2014 polls?

India needs a broader and more realistic de facto definition of the poor

Will poverty in India 'officially' end in a decade? If we scrutinise the Planning Commission's latest statistics thoroughly, it suggests so if the current trend continues. Arguably, the plan panel claims that poverty incidence had declined from 37.2% of the population in 2004-05 to 21.9% in 2011-12 - a decline of 15.3 percentage points in a period that roughly coincides with the first eight years of the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) rule at the Centre. In absolute terms, 137.4 million people were lifted above the poverty line over the seven-year period. Compared with 407.2 million poor people in 2004-05, the number came down to 269.7 million in 2011-12 - a reduction of 33%.
Will poverty in India ‘officially’ end in a decade? If we scrutinise the Planning Commission’s  latest statistics thoroughly, it suggests so if the current trend continues. Arguably, the plan panel claims that poverty incidence had declined from 37.2% of the population in 2004-05 to 21.9% in 2011-12 — a decline of 15.3 percentage points in a period that roughly coincides with the first eight years of the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) rule at the Centre.

In absolute terms, 137.4 million people were lifted above the poverty line over the seven-year period. Compared with 407.2 million poor people in 2004-05, the number came down to 269.7 million in 2011-12 — a reduction of 33%.
 
On Thursday, after Congress leader Raj Babbar's comment that a hearty meal in Mumbai can be bought for Rs 12 triggered a nation-wide controversy, another leader Raseed Massod claimed just Rs 5 was sufficient for it in Delhi. Can a party that claims to be pro-poor tolerate shockingly insensitive comments made by their leaders? To exploit the Commission data advocating decline in poverty backfired on the Congress as the focus shifted to concerns over rising inflation and the inequality between the rich and the poor.

The pertinent questions about inflation and inadequate resources available with the under-privileged drowned the bid after figures on the so-called poverty meltdown became public. According to the latest poverty estimate, those who are desperately poor in the country have to subsist on just Rs 33.33 per day in urban areas and Rs 27.20 in rural areas. This is marginally higher than the figures tentatively announced last March of Rs 32 in urban areas and Rs 26 in rural areas.

\"\"
The Poverty Line for 2011-12 has been estimated at Rs 816 per capita per month in rural areas and Rs 1000 in urban areas for the year 2011-12. That means a family of five living on the edge of poverty would have to survive on Rs 4,080 per month in rural areas and Rs 5,000 per month in urban areas, according to the Planning Commission.

Despite the recent uproar over the appallingly low level at which the Suresh Tendulkar committee set the poverty line, the government has chosen to stick officially with that line even though it knows that for all practical purposes the incidence of actual poverty is nearly three times higher.
 
While the plan panel-derived poverty lines and estimates have been all-important in the past because they are used to draw up BPL lists and allot entitlements, their inappropriateness is demonstrated by the fact that the government itself is now moving away from using these numbers altogether. According to a report in The Hindu,  Rukmini S and MK Venu say that following the Cabinet’s clearing of the National Food Security Ordinance, the plan panel has estimated that subsidised foodgrain entitlements will cover 67% of the population. Simultaneously, economists advising the Ministry of Rural Development have told the southern-based newspaper that the exclusion criteria to be derived from the ongoing Socio-Economic and Caste Census are likely to leave out the top 35% of the population while the bottom 65% will be considered below poverty line (BPL).
 
The article further quoting Planning Commission member Saumitra Chaudhuri says that by covering 67% of the population, the government is in effect drawing the poverty line 85% higher than what it is currently drawn at.
 
The poverty numbers are estimated on the basis of consumption expenditure captured in the five-year surveys undertaken by the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO). The decline in poverty numbers was first reported by The Hindu on 16 July.
 
The last one was made in 2009-10. Logically, the next one should have been in 2014-15.  But 2009-10 was not a “normal year” because of a severe drought. That’s why the NSS decided to repeat the large-scale survey in 2011-12. Breaking with the tradition of bringing it out every five years, the Manmohan Singh  government came under scathing attack for bringing out the poverty estimate three years ahead of schedule.
 
The World Bank has adopted a universal thumb rule: it says those living on less than $1.25 a day should be considered poor. The rupee’s value against the dollar averaged 47.85 in 2011-12. The purchasing power parity (PPP) rate for the rupee against the dollar could be arrived at by dividing the average exchange rate by 2.55. So, at the 2011-12 exchange rate of Rs 47.85 a dollar, the PPP rate would be Rs 18.76. The $1.25 poverty line at that PPP rate would mean Rs 23.45 — less than India’s poverty line for both rural and urban areas as announced for 2011-12. 
 
Some economists are of the view that economic realities, such as high inflation, rent and commodities, mean it is impossible to make even bare minimum purchases of food with such small amounts of money. The average cost of 1 kilogram of rice sold through the government’s public distribution system at subsidised rates for instance is currently around Rs18-20. The estimates don’t present a real picture of the number of those who live in very poor conditions, critics add. NC Saxena, a former bureaucrat who monitors food programmes on behalf of the Supreme Court of India, says the estimates of numbers living in poverty are meaningless in the current economic climate, reports the WSJ.
 
The formula used to measure poverty in the current report had been suggested in 2009 by Suresh Tendulkar. It had been widely criticised for underestimating consumption expenditure in the country. Last June, the Planning Commission had appointed a committee headed by C. Rangarajan, chairman of the Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council, to revise the poverty measurement formula. The committee is expected to submit its report in the middle of next year.
image

Read More

Jewel or bauble debate?

What started with a remark made by the Nobel laureate, lead to the BJP losing no time in asking the next NDA govt to strip Sen off his Bharat Ratna

Recommended for you

Advertisements

Columnists Rss icon

Shyam Ponappa

Shyam Ponappa: Path-breaking models for India?
Shyam Ponappa

Examples of coordinated initiatives if they can be made to work

Barun Roy

Barun Roy: Will India join the game?
Barun Roy

India has the necessary talent and financial muscle to become a major printing hub in the Asian region. But it remains to be seen if it has the ...

Editorial Comment Rss icon

A good effort

But foreign trade policy alone will not boost competitiveness

The urea problem

Now, it is time to decontrol prices

TWEETS @ POLITICS
@SinghRPN
First Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti, now Giriraj Singh, Modi's Ministers are a #NationalShame
@milinddeora
Loving the #BeiberRoast on @ComedyCentralIn!!!
@digvijaya_28
April Fool's day or Feku Jumla Day now ?
@thekiranbedi
(Way forward) @TimesNow: PM Narendra Modi having an informal interaction with the Secretaries to Government of India http://t.co/w7kvz8sOQY
@ajaymaken
Welcome to the #FekuDay- Two fake leaders in past one year-assuming power with fake promises and false perceptions! जनता माफ़ नहीं करेगी!
@MPNaveenJindal
RT @JSPLCorporate: 95% of #OPJCC alumni got selected for the Industrial Trainee post through a recruitment drive held by... http://t.co/spt
@Panda_Jay
My Twitter handle changed yesterday to @PandaJay 😊, please follow that..
@ShashiTharoor
RT @Fairoz_JK: @ShashiTharoor tweet & pray for Kashmir Highly appreciated
@Swamy39
Today I shall leave for London and tour UK for five days to speak to patriotic Indians residents
@narendramodi
Had an interaction with the Secretaries to the Government of India. http://t.co/bW4kgiwYve http://t.co/B5c96NNXFF
@abdullah_omar
RT @JKNC_: NC General Secretary Ali Mohammad Sagar toured areas of Dal Lake, Hazratbal and Khanyar today. Assessed situation. http://t.co/d
@varungandhi80
My article on India's environmental policy in The Asian Age/Deccan Chronicle today: http://t.co/Bq2GCvpIjA
@ArvindKejriwal
RT @AamAadmiParty: .@DrKumarVishwas speaks his heart out at AAP NC meeting. Must watch and share! https://t.co/OIpZJgUsLR
@PMOIndia
RT @Gen_VKSingh: 350 Indians evacuated from Aden by INS Sumitra arrived at Djibouti. http://t.co/6xdH77PuXo
@rajeev_mp
RT @wenayaradhya: @iVoteForBest @astitvam @VishweshwarBhat @rajeev_mp @KarnatakaVarthe @tv9kannada @Veerashaiva @divyaspandana http://t.co
@quizderek
@JohnRayhan The power of the Internet :)
@
Travel industry sees spurt in start-ups http://t.co/ItT09AvXzv
@SushmaSwaraj
If no clearance received, we will evacuate you by ship reaching Hodeidah port on 4th midnight. @mkloka
@arunjaitley
I congratulate Saina Nehwal on becoming the world no.1 badminton player. She is the first Indian woman to achieve this historic feat.
@MVENKAIAHNAIDU
Rs.276.92 Crore worth housing projects are reinstated in Andhra Pradesh. Vizag, Vijayawada &Tirupati got the approvals for housing projects.
@nitin_gadkari
Discussed various projects concerning the state. I am sure Karnataka will play a crucial role in taking India's economy forward
@DVSBJP
RT @bjpkarnataka: BJP is determined to conquer South India..BJP National Executive to be held in Bengaluru, 4th time in Karnataka http://t.
@umasribharti
चन्‍द्रशेखर राव को बधाई. तेलंगाना राज्‍य का मेरा संकल्‍प एवं सपना पूरा, तेलंगाना की नदियों का ध्‍यान रखेंगें.
@AnanthKumar_BJP
Inauguration of Vishwa Kannadigara Jagruthi Samavesha Venue: Gayathri Vihara, Palace Ground, Bengaluru 29-March-2015 http://t.co/pCYAuhjcMF
@smritiirani
RT @HRDMinistry: Watch the New Education Policy TVC https://t.co/6pW3ci8vEz and send us your suggestions https://t.co/Br6iPphZ2M
@drharshvardhan
Saina Nehwal - Congratulations U have done us proud by your historic win-Being the first Indian woman to become World Champion in badminton.
@Gen_VKSingh
350 Indians evacuated from Aden by INS Sumitra arrived at Djibouti. http://t.co/6xdH77PuXo
@Rao_InderjitS
Paid tribute to Martyr Lt. Kiran Shekhawat who laid down her life in the service of nation. http://t.co/ft0GEEtyqL
@nsitharaman
Waiting in Doha/Qatar for a connecting flight back to Delhi. A good, engaging visit to Jordan.
@RSSorg
श्री रामनवमी की शुभकामनाएं http://t.co/aNevXeA7FI

Back to Top