Business Standard

Sebi mulls exempting govt from open offer obligation

The regulator might also relax creeping acquisition rules

Related News

Markets regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) is planning to introduce a set of for the government that will be different from what private companies follow.

The proposal, on the drawing board, intends to exempt the government from making the mandatory open offer to buy an additional 26 per cent from minority shareholders if its stake in a company crosses 25 per cent.

The move comes in the wake of a recent instance where the government was exempted from making an open offer in financial institution Ltd, after its holding in the firm jumped from a marginal 0.0000011 per cent to 55.57 per cent, following conversion of warrants into shares in September.
 

SPECIAL TREATMENT
Instances when market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) had to exempt the government from open offer obligation
  • IFCI (September 24, 2012): The conversion of debentures worth Rs 923 crore had led to the government’s stake going up from 0.0000011% to 55.57%, resulting in acquiring control of IFCI
  • (March 26, 2012): Conversion of Tier-I bonds increased the government’s shareholding from 65.13% to 70.73%, breaching the creeping acquisition limit of 5%
  • Hindustan Copper (October 1, 2004): Issuances of equity shares worth Rs 365 crore to the government had led to an increase in government’s shareholding from 98.95% to 99.48%

“Although IFCI was a genuine case for exemption, we are looking whether we can have specific exemptions for the government under the (Takeover Code) Regulations,” said a senior official, requesting anonymity. He said the proposal was at a nascent stage and the contours of the rules were being discussed.

Sebi might also tweak rules for the government in cases of creeping acquisition, where buyers have to make an open offer it they purchase more than five per cent in a company in a financial year

In March, the regulator had exempted the government from making an open offer for IDBI Bank Ltd, when a proposed into the bank crossed the creeping acquisition limit of five per cent.

Sebi had introduced the new takeover code last year, increasing the open offer trigger limit from 15 per cent to 25 per cent. Also, it raised the minimum open offer required to be made by the acquirer to 26 per cent from 20 per cent.

Securities lawyers said a different set of laws for government companies would be detrimental to the interests of minority shareholders, though rules allow Sebi to do so.

“One objective of governance through regulators is to provide a level-playing field to both government participants and non-government participants. Preferential treatment to the government as acquirers under the takeover code would distort the level-playing field, which is already distorted on many other counts,” said M S Sahoo, a former whole-time member of Sebi and a lawyer.

The rationale behind the open offer obligation, which in some countries is as high as 100 per cent, is to give an opportunity to the minority shareholders to exit if they don't wish to continue with the new management in case of change in control.

Pavan Vijay, founder of corporate services provider Corporate Professionals, said: “In my view, giving automatic exemption to the government will not be justified from the point of view of minority shareholders. They should be given the opportunity to exit whenever there is an acquisition of shares of a listed company beyond the specific threshold, whether the said acquisition is by the government or by private parties.”

Lawyers said securities laws in the country are already partly distorted in certain cases. One is that the minimum public shareholding requirement for a public sector undertaking is much lower at 10 per cent than that for private sector companies, which is 25 per cent.

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

Sebi mulls exempting govt from open offer obligation

The regulator might also relax creeping acquisition rules

Markets regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) is planning to introduce a set of takeover rules for the government that will be different from what private companies follow.

Markets regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) is planning to introduce a set of for the government that will be different from what private companies follow.

The proposal, on the drawing board, intends to exempt the government from making the mandatory open offer to buy an additional 26 per cent from minority shareholders if its stake in a company crosses 25 per cent.

The move comes in the wake of a recent instance where the government was exempted from making an open offer in financial institution Ltd, after its holding in the firm jumped from a marginal 0.0000011 per cent to 55.57 per cent, following conversion of warrants into shares in September.
 

SPECIAL TREATMENT
Instances when market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) had to exempt the government from open offer obligation
  • IFCI (September 24, 2012): The conversion of debentures worth Rs 923 crore had led to the government’s stake going up from 0.0000011% to 55.57%, resulting in acquiring control of IFCI
  • (March 26, 2012): Conversion of Tier-I bonds increased the government’s shareholding from 65.13% to 70.73%, breaching the creeping acquisition limit of 5%
  • Hindustan Copper (October 1, 2004): Issuances of equity shares worth Rs 365 crore to the government had led to an increase in government’s shareholding from 98.95% to 99.48%

“Although IFCI was a genuine case for exemption, we are looking whether we can have specific exemptions for the government under the (Takeover Code) Regulations,” said a senior official, requesting anonymity. He said the proposal was at a nascent stage and the contours of the rules were being discussed.

Sebi might also tweak rules for the government in cases of creeping acquisition, where buyers have to make an open offer it they purchase more than five per cent in a company in a financial year

In March, the regulator had exempted the government from making an open offer for IDBI Bank Ltd, when a proposed into the bank crossed the creeping acquisition limit of five per cent.

Sebi had introduced the new takeover code last year, increasing the open offer trigger limit from 15 per cent to 25 per cent. Also, it raised the minimum open offer required to be made by the acquirer to 26 per cent from 20 per cent.

Securities lawyers said a different set of laws for government companies would be detrimental to the interests of minority shareholders, though rules allow Sebi to do so.

“One objective of governance through regulators is to provide a level-playing field to both government participants and non-government participants. Preferential treatment to the government as acquirers under the takeover code would distort the level-playing field, which is already distorted on many other counts,” said M S Sahoo, a former whole-time member of Sebi and a lawyer.

The rationale behind the open offer obligation, which in some countries is as high as 100 per cent, is to give an opportunity to the minority shareholders to exit if they don't wish to continue with the new management in case of change in control.

Pavan Vijay, founder of corporate services provider Corporate Professionals, said: “In my view, giving automatic exemption to the government will not be justified from the point of view of minority shareholders. They should be given the opportunity to exit whenever there is an acquisition of shares of a listed company beyond the specific threshold, whether the said acquisition is by the government or by private parties.”

Lawyers said securities laws in the country are already partly distorted in certain cases. One is that the minimum public shareholding requirement for a public sector undertaking is much lower at 10 per cent than that for private sector companies, which is 25 per cent.

image

Read More

Sebi exempts CARE Ratings from IPO grading process

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has exempted rating agency Credit Analysis and Research (CARE Ratings) from the mandatory grading ...

Recommended for you

Advertisements

Quick Links

Market News

Nifty holds 8450; SBI ends 2.4% lower post results

Sensex ends 148 points higher at 27,957. HDFC, ONGC, TCS gain

Sensex ends above 27,900 amid volatile session

Provisionally, the Sensex gained 134.71 points to end at 27,944.06 and the Nifty rose 27.80 points to close at 8,448.80

Sangam (India) zooms over 50% in four days on stake hike by promoter

The stock is currently trading at its record high of Rs 125 and has rallied 54% from Rs 81 on May 19.

Sagar Cements surges after turnaround in Q4

The stock surged 16% to Rs 408 after reported net profit of Rs 21.70 crore in March quarter against loss of Rs 11.36 crore in the year ago ...

SBI pares early gains post Q4 results

The stock surged 5% to Rs 305 after reported 23% year on year jump in standalone net profit at Rs 3,742 crore in March quarter.

 

Back to Top