You are here: Home » Current Affairs » Climate Change » News
Business Standard

Developing countries unite on CBDR principle

Rich countries go back on 2011 commitment, block every proposal to honour UN convention

Nitin Sethi  |  Paris 

Paris climate talks

A full-blown argument between the developed and developing countries over the application of principle of common but differentiated responsibilities (CBDR) in the Agreement rocked the summit as it drew closer to the end of the first week of negotiations.

After the developed countries blocked every proposal to incorporate CBDR in the Agreement, developing countries came out with scathing comments in public.

CBDR establishes that every country is responsible for addressing yet not equally responsible. It seeks to balance the need for all countries to take responsibility for and the need to recognise the differences in levels of economic development between countries. This principle is enshrined in the Framework Convention on (UNFCCC) and distinguishes between obligations of the rich countries, based on their historical responsibility in causing climate change, and the developing world.

All countries had previously agreed that the Agreement would be stitched under the Convention, which implied following its provisions and principles. But ever since the negotiations began in Paris, developed countries have steadfastly lobbied to do away with the differentiation.

Speaking for the Like-Minded Developing Countries, including and China, Gurdial Singh Nijar of Malaysia said, “You (the developed countries) grew to this level of prosperity because you burnt fossil fuel at an unabated rate… You created the problem and now you say that we want you to share—on an equal basis—the responsibility.”

“You signed on the Convention (UNFCCC). It was in 1992. You acknowledged historical responsibility. You acknowledged differentiation. You acknowledged a way out of the situation, but now you are resiling from your obligations. You assumed legally binding obligations, which you have not fulfilled,” he added.

The previous four days had seen the developed countries blocking every proposal on implementing the differentiation principle in various elements of the proposed agreement. These elements of the agreement are about reducing emissions, adapting to inevitable and providing means of implementation – technology, finance and capacity building.

“You are trying to freeze the development pace of developing countries. This is the message we want to give you. We don’t want to persuade you. You won’t be persuaded. You talk of countries like and China. They are big countries. Even if they add a little, it will increase a lot. Do people stop industrialization that meets the needs of the country? Do people stop eating?” Nijar said.

His statement came on a day when found support from an unexpected quarter – the Least Developed Countries (LDCs). Some have often contended that India’s demand for equity comes at the cost of threat to the LDCs. This includes India’s ex-environment minister Jairam Ramesh.

But in Paris, Pa Ousman, environment minister of Gambia, a prominent representative of the LDC group defended India’s right to development while doing more on renewable energy. He said, “is a developing country with millions of poor people. Economic situation in some parts of is the same as LDCs. We need to understand where is coming from and must appreciate the efforts of the (Indian) government.”

is in a different situation compared to China and others from our perspective. It’s fair for to protect the hundreds of millions of the poor,” he added.

Ousman’s statement deflates claims of those who had predicted that would be isolated at the talks for demanding that the Agreement should follow the convention. In 2011, when negotiations for the new pact began, all countries had agreed to follow the convention.

The positive note from LDCs came after the Africa group, G77+China supported the call that differentiation must be one of the guiding principles of all provisions in the new pact.

First Published: Sat, December 05 2015. 00:40 IST