Business Standard

Narendra Modi: Silent PM 2.0?

If under Manmohan Singh, there was an information deficit, under Modi there is a dialogue deficit.We now have a PM who speaks often, but only from behind the social media smokescreen.

Nikhil Inamdar  |  Mumbai 

Aruna Roy, Romila Thapar, Mrinal Pande, Jean Dreze, Anand Patwardhan and Mallika Sarabhai are among the prominent set of civil society activists who are signatories to a joint statement in which they have lashed out against Prime Minister for his silence on the brutal attack on Mohsin Shaikh, the techie who was killed allegedly by members of the Hindu Rashtra Sena.

Press reports suggest that the statement also expresses concern on the resurgence of assaults particularly on writers, academicians and thinkers and seeks the deletion of "regressive legislations" such as section 66(A) of the IT Act which is being flagrantly misused to quell political dissent.
 
There are several of a lesser distinction who've been equally perplexed by Narendra Modi's decision not to voice his unequivocal condemnation of  Shaikh's murder. He has, as it has turned out,had nothing to do with the circulation of morphed online photographs of that triggered the violence in Pune where fear seems to have gripped certain Muslim dominated boroughs. So much so that people have been driven to shave off beards and avoid skull caps in order to keep away from being targeted according to a Times of India report. Minor riots in the city, where Madrassas were being vandalized with orange flags hoisted over them were on for about a week before this incident took place, writes Rana Ayyub in the DNA.
 
What, if not such communal mischief must get the Prime Minister of India to wake up and assuage the disquiet that could be simmering among India's Muslims? Isn't Modi worried that his silence could be misconstrued, especially by those already suspicious of him, as an endorsement of such fringe activity? Shouldn't workers of the and who were also allegedly part of the violent protests that saw 130 buses and 20 vehicles damaged and a dozen injured in stone pelting know that their PM disapproves of such vandalism? What's really stopping him from issuing a simple message of commiseration for the victims when according to a report in this newspaper the PM sends out 10 to 15 communiqués per day through  a combination of tweets, posts, press releases and announcements on a wide ranging set of subjects? Surely it's not that that his media team is pressed for time.
 
Regrettably silence is what Narendra Modi has often chosen on ticklish issues. He may've been an efficient communicator on social media, but has effectively shielded himself from any meaningful media questions. If under Manmohan Singh, there was an information deficit, under Modi there seems to be a dialogue deficit. We now have a Prime Minister who speaks far too often, but only after he hides behind the social media smokescreen. He does not believe in directly answering questions we may want to ask him. And it seems to be that we may soon have an entire government that is loathe to interaction with members of the press. Modi has reportedly asked his cabinet ministers to refrain from speaking to journalists letting only official spokespersons do the job according to Scroll.in.
 
If such caginess in the Prime Minister is unfortunate, what is  even sadder is the fact that eminent members of the press and society - those that rallied behind Modi during the elections, seem to approve of this style. Journalist in her Sunday column for the Indian Express mockingly dismisses those that have sought a comment from the PM on the Pune violence.
 
''Tch, tch, tch, they said often last week, he should have spoken up when the young Muslim computer engineer was killed in that random attack by Hindu thugs in Pune'' Singh writes, speculating why Modi may not have demanded an explanation from Maharashtra's Congress Chief Minister. He wouldn't want to antagonize states with whom he needs to work  to bring about the change and development he has promised she reckons.
 
The responses she received to her column were even more worrying.
 
Sample this - 
 
"@dhume @tavleen_singh The public apparently thinks PM should be approached for everything including the clogged drain outside! :-) or :(", tweeted - Former Chief Economic Advisor to the Government of India.
 
Is expecting the PM to speak out against the murder of an innocent professional the same as demanding his attention to clogged drains? This is the mother of all inappropriate statements, save Modi's own puppy remark. And weren't these the same set of people who clobbered Manmohan Singh for his silence on issues in general?
 
If for nothing else,  then it is for the attention his silence is diverting from some of the brilliant initiatives the PM has set in motion in such a short span, that he must speak out. And even more so, because the admirers who've jumped to his defense are hampering rather than helping his case with their tactless remarks.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Narendra Modi: Silent PM 2.0?

If under Manmohan Singh, there was an information deficit, under Modi there is a dialogue deficit.We now have a PM who speaks often, but only from behind the social media smokescreen.

Aruna Roy, Romila Thapar, Mrinal Pande, Jean Dreze, Anand Patwardhan and Mallika Sarabhai are among the prominent set of civil society activists who are signatories to a joint statement in which they have lashed out against Prime Minister Narendra Modi for his silence on the brutal attack on Mohsin Shaikh, the Pune techie who was killed allegedly by members of the Hindu Rashtra Sena. Press reports suggest that the statement also expresses concern on the resurgence of assaults particularly on writers, academicians and thinkers and seeks the deletion of "regressive legislations" such as section 66(A) of the IT Act which is being flagrantly misused to quell political dissent.
Aruna Roy, Romila Thapar, Mrinal Pande, Jean Dreze, Anand Patwardhan and Mallika Sarabhai are among the prominent set of civil society activists who are signatories to a joint statement in which they have lashed out against Prime Minister for his silence on the brutal attack on Mohsin Shaikh, the techie who was killed allegedly by members of the Hindu Rashtra Sena.

Press reports suggest that the statement also expresses concern on the resurgence of assaults particularly on writers, academicians and thinkers and seeks the deletion of "regressive legislations" such as section 66(A) of the IT Act which is being flagrantly misused to quell political dissent.
 
There are several of a lesser distinction who've been equally perplexed by Narendra Modi's decision not to voice his unequivocal condemnation of  Shaikh's murder. He has, as it has turned out,had nothing to do with the circulation of morphed online photographs of that triggered the violence in Pune where fear seems to have gripped certain Muslim dominated boroughs. So much so that people have been driven to shave off beards and avoid skull caps in order to keep away from being targeted according to a Times of India report. Minor riots in the city, where Madrassas were being vandalized with orange flags hoisted over them were on for about a week before this incident took place, writes Rana Ayyub in the DNA.
 
What, if not such communal mischief must get the Prime Minister of India to wake up and assuage the disquiet that could be simmering among India's Muslims? Isn't Modi worried that his silence could be misconstrued, especially by those already suspicious of him, as an endorsement of such fringe activity? Shouldn't workers of the and who were also allegedly part of the violent protests that saw 130 buses and 20 vehicles damaged and a dozen injured in stone pelting know that their PM disapproves of such vandalism? What's really stopping him from issuing a simple message of commiseration for the victims when according to a report in this newspaper the PM sends out 10 to 15 communiqués per day through  a combination of tweets, posts, press releases and announcements on a wide ranging set of subjects? Surely it's not that that his media team is pressed for time.
 
Regrettably silence is what Narendra Modi has often chosen on ticklish issues. He may've been an efficient communicator on social media, but has effectively shielded himself from any meaningful media questions. If under Manmohan Singh, there was an information deficit, under Modi there seems to be a dialogue deficit. We now have a Prime Minister who speaks far too often, but only after he hides behind the social media smokescreen. He does not believe in directly answering questions we may want to ask him. And it seems to be that we may soon have an entire government that is loathe to interaction with members of the press. Modi has reportedly asked his cabinet ministers to refrain from speaking to journalists letting only official spokespersons do the job according to Scroll.in.
 
If such caginess in the Prime Minister is unfortunate, what is  even sadder is the fact that eminent members of the press and society - those that rallied behind Modi during the elections, seem to approve of this style. Journalist in her Sunday column for the Indian Express mockingly dismisses those that have sought a comment from the PM on the Pune violence.
 
''Tch, tch, tch, they said often last week, he should have spoken up when the young Muslim computer engineer was killed in that random attack by Hindu thugs in Pune'' Singh writes, speculating why Modi may not have demanded an explanation from Maharashtra's Congress Chief Minister. He wouldn't want to antagonize states with whom he needs to work  to bring about the change and development he has promised she reckons.
 
The responses she received to her column were even more worrying.
 
Sample this - 
 
"@dhume @tavleen_singh The public apparently thinks PM should be approached for everything including the clogged drain outside! :-) or :(", tweeted - Former Chief Economic Advisor to the Government of India.
 
Is expecting the PM to speak out against the murder of an innocent professional the same as demanding his attention to clogged drains? This is the mother of all inappropriate statements, save Modi's own puppy remark. And weren't these the same set of people who clobbered Manmohan Singh for his silence on issues in general?
 
If for nothing else,  then it is for the attention his silence is diverting from some of the brilliant initiatives the PM has set in motion in such a short span, that he must speak out. And even more so, because the admirers who've jumped to his defense are hampering rather than helping his case with their tactless remarks.
image

Columnists

Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine

Twitter Feed

  • @SinghRPN

    RT @OfficeOfRG: So I say to them keep attacking my family, it won't make a difference to me. I am here to defend the freedom of the people …

  • @milinddeora

    Not just India Inc, but all of India has the right to critique parliament. But please be consistent while doing so

  • @digvijaya_28

    http://t.co/0rG6oDNQfi Through my letter to Director CBI I have pointed out the gaps in STF investigation and tampering of the evidence.

  • @thekiranbedi

    New record set in my life.. By addressing such a large audience in Netaji Stadium..Hare Krishna. http://t.co/RMvyUQvaQU

  • @ajaymaken

    RT @Kundra_Vishal: अनशन पर बैठे @ajaymaken जी के साथ जिस तरह पटरी वालो का हुजूम जुटा लग रहा था हम फिरसे स्वतंत्रता की लड़ाई लड़ रहे हैं htt…

  • @MPNaveenJindal

    Thanks for Sharing. Today we @FFOIndia commissioned 64th Monumental #Tiranga at Jalandhar... https://t.co/nBHNinYYiL

  • @Panda_Jay

    My Twitter handle changed yesterday to @PandaJay 😊, please follow that..

  • @ShashiTharoor

    The @RobinHood_Army aims to unite students across India-Pak to serve 1 lakh people across the border #Mission100k http://t.co/DaZPpfCtl7

  • @Swamy39

    @shinustalin : Why? BJP has more potential than any other party. We can make course corrections

  • @narendramodi

    Am extremely happy to know that PAHAL scheme has set the Guinness world record for the Largest Cash Transfer Programme. @GWR

  • @abdullah_omar

    "Violence & talks can't go together" BJP circa 2004-2014. This is one U turn I'm very glad to see. Hope #NSAtalks lay strong foundation.

  • @varungandhi80

    Interesting, principled stand by @poonam_mahajan. https://t.co/ediMNjy5m9

  • @ArvindKejriwal

    RT @RamaNewDelhi: Last year, CM Kejriwal protested on the street! Today the entire Modi cabinet was on the street to protest! Govts protest…

  • @PMOIndia

    Welcoming the world to India. #IncredibleIndia http://t.co/Pc9Cbsh7lL

  • @rajeev_mp

    @thewire_in reports on @rsprasad 's response to my Parliament Question on #Privacy https://t.co/SHKr1DWJoJ

  • @quizderek

    @Sir_R_U_L @madversity Same apply for Salmaan Khan

  • @

    Tata Power beats estimates, reports Q1 profit of Rs 241 crore http://t.co/ew19wJeA2v

  • @SushmaSwaraj

    Thank you Prime Minister. https://t.co/PBfctpZag6

  • @arunjaitley

    THE MONSOON SESSION - IS IT INDIA’S LOSS? http://t.co/7Yc8g2iPTC

  • @MVENKAIAHNAIDU

    When you are not well on the facts, go to the well of the house(Parliament), said one great leader.

  • @nitin_gadkari

    Inaugurated the two day International Conference & Exhibition on Public Transport Innovation organised by ASRTU http://t.co/pifPFBCWHu

  • @DVSBJP

    RT @narendramodi: Sharp and pointed speech by Shri @arunjaitley in the Lok Sabha today. https://t.co/tDrqdfeCir

  • @umasribharti

    चन्‍द्रशेखर राव को बधाई. तेलंगाना राज्‍य का मेरा संकल्‍प एवं सपना पूरा, तेलंगाना की नदियों का ध्‍यान रखेंगें.

  • @AnanthKumar_BJP

    RT @narendramodi: Am extremely happy to know that PAHAL scheme has set the Guinness world record for the Largest Cash Transfer Programme. @…

  • @smritiirani

    RT @narendramodi: Sharp and pointed speech by Shri @arunjaitley in the Lok Sabha today. https://t.co/tDrqdfeCir

  • @drharshvardhan

    Praying to God for the peace of the Soul of a great President known as the Missile Man.The Nation&particularly students shall always miss u.

  • @Gen_VKSingh

    RT @narendramodi: A must-watch speech by @SushmaSwaraj ji in Parliament. https://t.co/Lpdg4wKcQf

  • @Rao_InderjitS

    RT @SpokespersonMoD: #IndependenceDay 2015: RRM @Rao_InderjitS giving away gifts to participating contingents at Rehearsal at #RedFort. htt…

  • @nsitharaman

    RT @narendramodi: Sharp and pointed speech by Shri @arunjaitley in the Lok Sabha today. https://t.co/tDrqdfeCir

  • @RSSorg

    Krishnappa Ji was a great organiser and inspiration to many Karyakartas & pioneered Kutumb Prabodhan activity in RSS: Dr Manmohan Vaidya