Business Standard

Ideology and India

Khurshid, speaking on ideology and politics, missed the point

Related News

Law Minister has insisted that his statements to The on the “rudderless” nature of the party have been “misinterpreted”. On the contrary, it appears that they were more than clear enough, and that they accurately reflect the views of a large and growing section of those within the ruling party. Mr Khurshid, speaking of the Congress, said that “we need a new to be given by our next-generation leader to move forward”, and that, so far, the Congress had seen only “cameos of his thought and ideas”. He is quite right that Mr Gandhi, a general secretary of the party and widely viewed as its next leader, has been too reticent about his opinions and suggestions on specific policy proposals. However, the larger drift of his argument appears to be both mistaken and misdirected, not “misinterpreted”.

First, Mr Khurshid is mistaken: it is far from clear that the Congress is in fact in need of a new ideology. The Congress’ historical ideology continues, apparently, to be on offer: left-of-centre compromise. The “reformists”, led by Prime Minister , push for growth that swells incomes and the exchequer; the “entitlers”, led by Congress President , push for the spread of rights and welfarist entitlements to India’s poor. Since 2004, it is clear that the policy programme the Congress offers is a compromise between these two viewpoints — or what it chooses to call “inclusive growth”. That UPA-II has largely failed to deliver either inclusion or growth is a reflection of administrative and political failures, not of direction. It is inconceivable that Mr Gandhi will alter the “inclusive growth” approach — so what ideological intervention is expected of him? Which should take the debate to the second point: how Mr Khurshid’s suggestions are misdirected. Mr Gandhi continues to show no inclination whatsoever to take up a post in government or to usurp his mother’s role as leader of the party. Given that the failures of UPA-II have been failures of and administration – an inability to push reform, restore growth and tackle corruption, the collapse of the Congress in Andhra Pradesh thanks to mismanagement of the Telangana issue, and an overall mishandling of its allies – Mr Khurshid’s complaints would have been better directed at the Congress party’s current leader, Sonia Gandhi. Or, indeed, at all his fellow Congressmen, with Mr Gandhi just one among their number. Nothing stops the Congress from conducting a lively internal debate on policy issues that can inform its future direction.

While the Congress’ confusions play out in public, however, it is notable that India’s other national formations may be even more ideologically adrift. The BJP, a party of nominal economic reformers, blocks essential reforms, like the goods and services tax, that it earlier supported. It is unclear whether it wants to be a party of hardline, authoritarian Hindutva – Narendra Modi’s party – or of softer, inclusive nationalism — Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s party. Meanwhile, the ideological divisions in India’s Communists are no longer concealed by their oaths of silence; student wings are rebelling against the “compromises” made by their parliamentarians, for example. India’s politics is not short of ideological conflict; it is just rarely seen clearly as such.

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

Read More

Unfair contract

Almost a third of India’s organised labour force is on contract. This is an inevitable consequence of archaic labour laws that make it impossible for ...


Quick Links

Have Your Say




What are your views on the sacking of two AAP members on charges of graft?

What are your views on the sacking of two AAP members on charges of graft?

Financial X-Ray Rss icon

UltraTech surprises Street with 9% volume, 13% PAT growth
Malini Bhupta

Valuations stretched as current price factors in 8% volume growth in FY15-16, which is unlikely to play out

New headaches for miners after Goa mining ban lifted
Malini Bhupta

The verdict on deemed licences has the Street question whether Sesa Sterlite owns any mines in Goa

Back to Top